Skip to content
CAI
Software that uses CAICheck a score

openjournals/joss

44.8

Weak · 6 November 2026

4.6k

lines of production code

Ruby

with JavaScript

4

measurements over time

CAI band scale
CAI trend line
CAI lens gauges

What this system is

Features

Added Rails application binstubs

The application now includes executable binstubs in the bin directory for core tools (rails, rake, bundle, rspec, importmap, setup). These scripts provide a consistent and isolated way to run commands using the project's specific gem versions, ensuring that development and deployment environments match the Gemfile dependencies.

bin · high confidence

Added brand and UI asset icons

The application now includes a set of new SVG image assets in the public assets directory. These additions include the official ORCID and Creative Commons logos, a DOI icon, GitHub branding, and a collection of generic UI icons (such as download, history, info, and document symbols) intended for use in the interface.

app/assets/images · high confidence

Added console helper to find papers by review or meta-review issue ID

A new \dat\ helper method has been added to the Rails console extensions, allowing users to quickly locate a paper by passing either its review issue ID or meta-review issue ID.

lib/util · high confidence

Database schema expansion for editorial workflows and submission controls

This update introduces a comprehensive set of database migrations that establish the underlying data structures for the journal's editorial and submission systems. Key additions include the creation of \tracks\ and \subjects\ to organize papers, a \votes\ table to support editor decision-making, and an \invitations\ model (with state tracking) to manage paper and onboarding assignments. The schema also adds \issue\_comments\ to track discussion activity, \blocklist\_entries\ to enforce submission restrictions, and \notes\ for internal editor communication. Furthermore, it enriches the \editors\ table with affiliation data, buddy assignments, and a shift from availability strings to a \max\_assignments\ integer, while \papers\ gain fields for git branches, retraction relationships, and submission kinds to support the full lifecycle of a submission.

db/migrate · high confidence

Editor in Chief dashboard now displays and paginates recent invitations

The Editor in Chief dashboard now includes a dedicated 'Invitations' section that lists recent invitations with editor details, paper titles, status, and creation time. Users can cancel pending invitations directly from this list, and the view supports pagination via Pagy to handle large numbers of invitations. The dashboard also filters invitations by track when a specific track is selected.

app/views/invitations · high confidence

Editor onboarding and invitation management interface

This change introduces the user interface for managing editor onboarding. The new editor registration form allows new editors to submit their profile details, including name, email, GitHub username, categories, and description, with an optional section for selecting tracks if the feature is enabled. Additionally, an admin dashboard page provides tools for Editors in Chief to invite new editors via email, view pending editor applications, and approve or re-send invitations to join the GitHub organization.

app/views/onboardings · high confidence

Initial CSS framework and UI styling for the application

This change introduces the foundational stylesheet architecture for the application, replacing the previous state with a new set of SCSS files. It establishes global styles including the Inter font family, smooth scrolling, and typography defaults. New layout and component styles are added for the home page hero section, paper listings and views (including badges and metadata), the editor dashboard (with status indicators and table styling), and session/login pages. Additionally, a reusable animation module is provided to support fade and transition effects across the interface.

app/assets/stylesheets · high confidence

Initial Rails 7.2 application configuration and routing setup

The application is now configured on Rails 7.2, loading environment-specific settings from YAML files and utilizing Puma as the web server. This update introduces a comprehensive routing structure that supports paper management, editor and reviewer dashboards, and API endpoints for external services like Whedon. It also enables real-time features via Redis Action Cable, integrates Hotwire (Turbo and Stimulus) for modern JavaScript interactions, and configures ORCID OAuth for authentication.

config · high confidence

Initial database schema and seed data for editorial workflow

The application now includes a defined database schema and seed data to support the core editorial workflow. The schema introduces tables for managing editors, papers, tracks, subjects, and user invitations, along with specific fields such as \git\_branch\ and \availability\_comment\ to track paper metadata and editor capacity. Seed data populates the initial editorial board with profiles, categories, and descriptions, establishing the foundational data structure for the platform.

db · high confidence

Initial implementation of application helper modules

This change introduces the foundational helper modules for the application, including ApplicationHelper, DispatchHelper, EditorsHelper, HomeHelper, InvitationsHelper, PaginationHelper, PapersHelper, and SessionsHelper. These modules provide core UI logic such as flash message styling, navigation link generation, editor availability calculations, paper status badges, and GitHub integration features like avatar display and user linking. The DispatchHelper specifically handles GitHub webhook payloads to sync paper activities, labels, and comments, while the PaginationHelper implements the pagy gem for list navigation.

app/helpers · high confidence

Initial implementation of the email notification system

Introduces the core mailer infrastructure for the application, including a base \ApplicationMailer\ that configures the default sender and layout. Adds a \Notifications\ mailer that defines specific email templates for key editorial workflows: notifying Associate Editors-in-Chief (AEICs) and editors of new paper submissions, alerting AEICs when a paper's track changes, sending editorial invites to authors, delivering weekly status updates to editors, providing scope-check summaries, and handling onboarding invitations for the editorial board.

app/mailers · high confidence

Initial layout structure with analytics, feeds, and social meta tags

The application now includes a main layout template that integrates Google Analytics tracking, defines dynamic page titles, and links to Atom feeds for paper submissions. It also configures Open Graph and Twitter Card meta tags for social sharing, includes favicon assets, and renders the navigation bar, flash messages, and footer across all pages. Additionally, basic HTML and text layouts are provided for email notifications.

app/views/layouts · high confidence

Initial project scaffolding and configuration

The repository has been initialized with the core structure for a Ruby on Rails application, including the Procfile to run the Puma web server, the Rakefile, and the Rack configuration file. Essential configuration files have been added, such as .ruby-version (set to 3.3.3), .rspec for test runner settings, and .pryrc for debugging aliases. The project also includes a .gitignore file to exclude build artifacts and environment files, an Aptfile for Heroku system dependencies, and a .readthedocs.yaml file to configure documentation builds. Additionally, this change introduces the Code of Conduct (CODE\_OF\_CONDUCT.md), Conflict of Interest policy (COI.md), and a comprehensive README.md with updated badges and development setup instructions.

(repo-wide) · high confidence

Initial public asset and error page scaffolding

The application now includes standard static files for the public directory, providing default error pages for HTTP 404, 406, 422, and 500 status codes to improve user feedback during errors. Additionally, web app manifest files (manifest.json, browserconfig.xml) and an SVG icon are added to support mobile home screen installation and browser tab icons, alongside a basic robots.txt file for search engine indexing guidance.

public · high confidence

Initial release of editorial dashboard and paper management controllers

This change introduces the core application controllers that power the editorial workflow and public-facing paper discovery. It adds the \AeicDashboardController\ for managing editorial board tasks, including CSV exports of editor emails, and the \HomeController\ which provides the main dashboard, paper listings (incoming, in-progress, all), and activity leaderboards for editors. The \PapersController\ handles public paper views, search, and filtering, while the \DispatchController\ exposes API endpoints for bot interactions (such as assigning editors, starting reviews, and depositing metadata). Additional controllers manage editor profiles (\EditorsController\), onboarding (\OnboardingsController\), paper notes and votes (\NotesController\, \VotesController\), and administrative resources like tracks and blocklists.

app/controllers · high confidence

Initial release of the JOSS editorial management application

This entry marks the initial commit of the Ruby on Rails application, introducing the core data models and business logic required for the journal's editorial workflow. The codebase establishes the foundational architecture including the ApplicationRecord base class, and defines key entities such as Paper, Editor, User, Track, Subject, and Vote. It implements the paper lifecycle state machine (AASM) for transitions like submission, review, acceptance, and retraction, alongside features for editor onboarding, invitation management, and submission blocklists. The diff also includes models for tracking issue comments and notes, setting the stage for the dashboard and API functionality described in subsequent changes.

ruby · high confidence

Initialize Stimulus application with autocomplete controller

The JavaScript frontend now initializes a Stimulus application instance, registering a global 'autocomplete' controller sourced from the 'stimulus-autocomplete' library. This setup enables autocomplete functionality for form fields, specifically supporting the new paper's subject input, by eagerly loading controllers defined in the import map.

app/javascript/controllers · high confidence

Introduce editorial tracks and issue header parsing

The library now supports a new 'tracks' system for organizing submissions by academic discipline, defined in the new \lib/tracks.yml\ file with fields, codes, and assigned editors. A new \IssueHeader\ module parses machine-readable headers in GitHub issues to extract reviewer and editor handles, handling case-insensitive deduplication. The \Repository\ module has been updated to load editor teams from GitHub and send invitations to the editors team, while \JournalFeatures\ and \SettingsHelper\ provide infrastructure for feature flags and settings access.

lib · high confidence

Introduces custom JavaScript modules for UI interactions

Adds several new client-side scripts to handle specific frontend behaviors: \clipboards.js\ implements copy-to-clipboard functionality using ClipboardJS with event prevention; \editors.js\ manages form field states based on editor selection; \home.js\ handles tab and menu navigation highlighting; \papers.js\ enables client-side table sorting via SortTable, manages paper layout resizing, and provides a badge copy button with responsive popover placement; \transitions.js\ adds fade-in/fade-out animations to the primary content area during page changes; and \loading\_jquery.js\ ensures jQuery is available globally for these scripts.

app/javascript/custom · high confidence

Introduction of ReviewIssue model for GitHub issue processing

A new ReviewIssue class has been added to the application models to handle the retrieval and filtering of review-related issues from GitHub. This class provides methods to download open and completed review issues, filtering out paused, withdrawn, or rejected items, and allows for the identification of issues assigned to specific editors. It serves as a helper to parse issue titles and bodies for review states and editor assignments, enabling the system to manage the review workflow more effectively.

app/models · high confidence

New AEiC dashboard with track filtering and editor email exports

A new Associate Editors-in-Chief (AEiC) dashboard has been added, providing a centralized view for managing editorial workflows. The main dashboard page displays lists of submissions labeled 'recommend-accept' and 'query-scope', with links to their corresponding GitHub issues. A key feature is the ability to filter these views by specific editorial tracks via a dropdown menu, which is conditionally rendered based on the 'tracks' feature flag. Additionally, a dedicated 'Editor emails' page allows users to download CSV files containing contact information for the editorial board and topic editors. The dashboard includes a navigation menu linking to editors, invitations, onboarding, and block list management.

_app/views/aeic\dashboard · high confidence

New Table of Contents views for browsing papers by year, volume, and issue

Added a set of ERB templates (index, year, volume, issue, current\_issue, and a shared list partial) that render a paginated table of papers. Users can now browse the publication archive by year, volume, and issue, with each paper entry displaying its title, DOI, and acceptance date formatted as YYYY-MM-DD.

app/views/toc · high confidence

New administrative rake tasks for editorial workflows and data maintenance

This change introduces a suite of new Rake tasks in lib/tasks to support editorial operations and data integrity. Editors can now receive automated weekly emails via \editorials:send\_weekly\_emails\ (scheduled for Mondays) and query-scope emails via \editorials:send\_query\_scope\_email\ (scheduled for Wednesdays). Data management is enhanced with \portico:deposit\ for archiving papers via SFTP, \sync:cleanup\_paper\_branches\ to remove obsolete GitHub branches, and \utils:sync\_reviewers\_from\_metadata\ / \utils:sync\_reviewers\_from\_github\ to keep reviewer lists consistent between the database, paper metadata, and GitHub issue headers. Additionally, \tracks:current\_info\ exports track/subject data to YAML, while \tracks:import:subjects\ and \tracks:import:dry\_run\ allow importing or previewing subject updates from a local YAML file, and \stats:most\_published\_authors\ generates a report of top authors.

lib/tasks · high confidence

New editor dashboard, statistics, and activity views

The application now includes dedicated views for the editor dashboard, statistics, and issue activity. The dashboard view displays a table of editor statistics (assigned papers, averages, and totals) and charts for accepted papers over time, with options to filter by editor or reviewer. The statistics view provides a high-level overview of paper counts. The activity view presents a leaderboard of accounts commenting on review issues, ranked by distinct issues and comment volume, with a detailed breakdown of comments for specific users. These views are supported by a new menu partial for navigation between dashboard sections and a profiles menu for user/editor profile access.

app/views/home · high confidence

New email templates for author, editor, and administrative notifications

This change introduces a comprehensive set of new email notification templates for the JOSS platform, covering the full lifecycle of paper submissions and editorial workflows. Authors now receive a confirmation email upon submission that sets expectations for triage wait times and directs them to GitHub for support. Editors are equipped with new invitation emails for accepting paper assignments, weekly digest emails providing a dashboard of assigned, closed, and pending papers, and scope-voting emails for reviewing flagged submissions. Additionally, new templates handle editor onboarding invitations, internal submission alerts, and track-change notifications for Associate Editors-in-Chief.

app/views/notifications · high confidence

New shared view templates for editor profiles, flash messages, and review workflows

This change introduces a set of new shared partials and templates in the views layer to standardize UI components and automate content generation for the submission and review process. Users will see consistent editor profiles (including avatars, board titles, and affiliations, with retired editors hidden), standardized flash message alerts, and a profile completion warning. Additionally, new templates handle the display of retraction notices, a scope update banner with a 30-day dismissal cookie, and the structured text bodies for meta-review and main-review GitHub issues, including status badges, editor/reviewer instructions, and checklist generation prompts.

app/views/shared · high confidence

Behavioural changes

About page content restructured into reusable partials

The About page content has been refactored into two new view partials: \_general.html.erb, which defines the journal's scope, submission workflow, and documentation links, and \_partnerships.html.erb, which details affiliations with the Open Source Initiative and NumFOCUS. This change improves content modularity and ensures consistent presentation of the journal's identity and organizational relationships.

app/views/content/about · high confidence

Configures asset manifest for Import Maps and CSS bundling

The application now uses a JavaScript-based asset manifest (manifest.js) to explicitly link stylesheets and JavaScript files. This configuration links the main application.css file and sets up link trees for images, stylesheets, and JavaScript sources, supporting the migration to Import Maps for module loading.

app/assets/config · high confidence

Editor management and track administration UI overhaul

The editor management interface has been significantly restructured to support a more detailed editor profile and flexible assignment limits. The new editor form and profile views allow administrators to set a 'Max number of assignments' (replacing previous availability flags), add availability comments, assign a 'buddy' editor, and manage categories, affiliations, and tracks. The editor list now displays start dates, current editing load, remaining capacity, and pending invites, with sortable columns. Additionally, a new track management section has been added, allowing admins to create, edit, and delete tracks, assign Associate Editors in Chief (AEiCs) to tracks, and handle paper reassignment when deleting a track.

app/views/editors · high confidence

Initial Rails environment configuration files added

The application now includes explicit configuration files for development, test, and production environments. Development mode enables code reloading, local error reporting, and local file storage for assets. Production mode enforces SSL, configures Sendgrid for email delivery, sets the application host, and explicitly disables YJIT. Test mode uses an in-memory cache, disables forgery protection, and routes emails to a test delivery method.

config/environments · high confidence

Migrate JavaScript to Import Maps with Turbo and Bootstrap

The application's JavaScript loading strategy has shifted to use Import Maps, consolidating dependencies into a single entry point. This change introduces Hotwired Turbo for navigation, Bootstrap for styling, and Chartkick for data visualization, while also organizing custom scripts for loading states, editors, home page, papers, sorting, and transitions.

app/javascript · high confidence

Migrate pagination to Pagy and update session expiration

The application has replaced the previous pagination system with Pagy, configuring a default page limit of 20 and setting the overflow policy to return an empty page. Additionally, the session cookie expiration has been extended to three months, and new MIME types for SVG and PDF responses have been registered to support badge generation and PDF outputs.

config/initializers · high confidence

Redesigned paper submission and review workflow

The paper submission and review interface has been significantly restructured. Authors now use a new submission form that supports multiple content types, subject autocomplete, and explicit submission categories (new, resubmission, major version). The paper show page is split into distinct views for unpublished and published papers; unpublished papers display editorial tools including a scope voting system with local storage persistence, editor notes, and metadata editing. Published papers feature an embedded PDF viewer, citation tools (BibTeX, citation string), and integration with Altmetric and Dimensions badges. Additionally, a new blocklist management interface allows Editors in Chief to block ORCID iDs, email addresses, and repositories to prevent future spam submissions.

app/views/papers · high confidence

The site's layout components have been updated to improve navigation and display current organizational affiliations. The new footer now explicitly displays the application's ISSN, links to the Table of Contents, and clarifies the project's status as an affiliate of the Open Source Initiative and a NumFOCUS-sponsored project under Open Journals. The navigation bar has been restructured to include a dedicated AEiC dashboard link for appropriate users, updated login/logout flows (using POST for ORCID login), and a consolidated RSS feed dropdown for accessing atom feeds of active and published papers.

app/views/content/layout · high confidence

Updated Bootstrap 4.3.1 stylesheets

The project has updated its Bootstrap 4.3.1 stylesheet components to the latest version. This change includes new or updated SCSS files for core UI elements such as alerts, badges, breadcrumbs, buttons, cards, carousels, dropdowns, forms, and modals, ensuring the application's visual presentation aligns with the updated library standards.

app/assets/stylesheets/bootstrap-4.3.1 · high confidence

Test coverage

Added RSpec test configuration files; Added controller specs for editorial dashboard, blocklist, badges, and dispatch; Added model specs for editorial workflow and blocklist components; Added system tests for editor management and profile pages; Added system tests for editorial dashboard, onboarding, and track management; Added system tests for paper search, show pages, and track management; Added test factories for core domain models; Added test support helpers for authentication, feature flags, and git command mocking; Added tests for editor availability helper; Added tests for issue header parsing, repository configuration, and track validation; Added tests for the Notifications mailer; Added view specs for editor forms and show page; Added view specs for paper submission forms and display pages.

Dependencies

Upgrade to Rails 7.2.3.1 and Ruby 3.3.3

The application runtime and framework have been upgraded to Ruby 3.3.3 and Rails 7.2.3.1. This update brings the app to the latest stable versions, ensuring compatibility with modern standards and including the latest security patches. The dependency manifest also reflects updates to key libraries such as Pagy (9.4.0), Honeybadger (5.2.0), and the addition of modern frontend tooling like Importmap, Turbo, and Stimulus.

(dependencies) · high confidence

Housekeeping

Added empty placeholder directories for vendor assets; Initial commit of Rails application.

Written by cca.canine.dev from the codebase's own history, inside the signed delivery this page is composed from.

How this codebase got here

Score

  • CAI 40 → 45 (+4.7)
  • Rubric changed (rubric-2026.10.5 → rubric-2026.11.2) — scores are not directly comparable.

Lenses

  • Code Health 44 → 44 (+0.0)
  • Architecture 86 → 86 (+0.0)
  • Maturity 34 → 50 (+16.1)
  • Readiness 49 → 48 (-0.1)
  • Security 57 → 56 (-1.0)
  • Domain Modelling 41 → 41 (+0.0)
  • Accessibility 52 → 52 (-0.0)

Resolved (10)

  • Critical CVE: [GHSA redacted] (Gemfile.lock)
  • High CVE: [GHSA redacted] (Gemfile.lock)
  • High CVE: [GHSA redacted] (Gemfile.lock)
  • High CVE: [GHSA redacted] (Gemfile.lock)
  • High CVE: [GHSA redacted] (Gemfile.lock)
  • Medium CVE: [GHSA redacted] (Gemfile.lock)
  • Medium CVE: [GHSA redacted] (Gemfile.lock)
  • Medium CVE: [GHSA redacted] (Gemfile.lock)
  • Medium CVE: [GHSA redacted] (Gemfile.lock)
  • Off-boarding risk: anonymized user #1

New (7)

  • Off-boarding risk: anonymized user #1
  • Outdated: chartkick
  • Outdated: csv
  • Outdated: net-sftp
  • Outdated: vcr
  • redundant comment (app/javascript/custom/home.js)
  • redundant comment (app/javascript/custom/home.js)

Changes since last survey

  • 6 commits — 6 feature/other, 0 fixes

By area

  • (root) — 3 commits
  • (repo) — 1 commit
  • .github/workflows — 1 commit
  • app/models — 1 commit

Notable commits

  • change: Add rack-timeout
  • change: Expire pending editor invitations when a paper is withdrawn
  • change: Merge pull request #1592 from openjournals/expire-invites-on-withdraw
  • change: Update Rails and dependencies
  • change: Update Ruby version to 3.4.12
  • change: Update Ruby version to 3.4.12

Architecture

  • Unchanged — 0 containers · 1 contexts · 0 edges

Written by cca.canine.dev from the codebase's own history, inside the signed delivery this page is composed from.

Survey your own repository

openjournals/joss was measured the same way every project in this corpus was: the same rubric, at a pinned commit, with the result published in full. Point a surveyor at a repository you know and see whether you agree with it.

About this page

  • The score is its most recent published measurement, taken on 6 November 2026 at a pinned commit. It is not a live figure and does not change until the project is measured again.
  • Measured at commit 657a0ad9207a932e8797d7016a174c350811f065 — the exact code this score is about.
  • Scored under rubric-2026.11.2 — the same rubric and the same method as every other entry in this index.
  • Measured by Canine Code Analyzer (cca.canine.dev) using cca measure-2026.11.2+preprod-5c4e66d9318b.