Skip to content
CAI
Software that uses CAICheck a score

samsonasik/ci4-album

64.8

Adequate · 22 September 2026

1.6k

lines of production code

PHP

primary language

7

measurements over time

CAI band scale
CAI trend line
CAI lens gauges

What this system is

This system is a CodeIgniter 4 application for managing albums and their associated tracks, providing full CRUD capabilities for both entities. It features a domain-driven architecture with SQL-based persistence, supporting paginated search, track summaries, and strict data validation to prevent duplicates. The application includes a Bootstrap-based web interface for user interaction and is backed by comprehensive unit and integration tests.

Features

Add paginated album track summary repository

A new SQL-based repository for album track summaries has been introduced, implementing the domain repository interface to fetch paginated data. This change enables users to retrieve album summaries with a total song count per album, supporting pagination via the configured page limit.

src/Infrastructure/Persistence/AlbumTrackSummary · high confidence

Add paginated album track summary view

A new view file for the album track summary has been added, displaying a table of albums with their ID, title, artist, and total song count. The view includes pagination support via a pager link and provides a fallback message when no summary data is available, along with a navigation link back to the album index.

src/Views/album-track-summary · high confidence

Added album track summary domain entity and repository interface

Introduced a new domain layer for album track summaries, consisting of an \AlbumTrackSummary\ entity class and an \AlbumTrackSummaryRepository\ interface. The entity models track summary data including artist, ID, title, and total song count, while the repository defines the contract for fetching paginated summary data.

src/Domain/AlbumTrackSummary · high confidence

Added database seeders for album and track data

New seed classes (AlbumSeeder and TrackSeeder) have been added to the src/Database/Seeds directory to populate the database with initial sample data. AlbumSeeder inserts a default album record, while TrackSeeder inserts a corresponding track record, both utilizing strict typing and final class declarations as per the project's coding standards.

src/Database/Seeds · high confidence

Added domain exception classes for duplicated and missing records

The application now includes specific domain exceptions, DuplicatedRecordException and RecordNotFoundException, which extend the standard PHP DomainException. These classes provide a protected constructor to set the error message, allowing the domain layer to throw distinct exception types for duplicate record attempts and missing record lookups, improving error handling clarity for users and developers.

src/Domain/Exception · high confidence

The album view layer now provides complete CRUD interfaces for albums. Users can add new albums via a dedicated form (src/Views/album/add.php) and edit existing ones (src/Views/album/edit.php), both featuring title and artist fields with validation error display. The album index page (src/Views/album/index.php) has been reorganized to include a search form, a flash message display area, and an 'Album Tracks Details' link for each album, allowing users to navigate to track summaries. The delete action now warns users that associated track records will also be deleted.

src/Views/album · high confidence

Album track management views added

New views have been added to allow users to manage album tracks. The index page displays a list of tracks for a specific album with search functionality and links to add, edit, or delete entries. The add and edit views provide forms to input the track title and author, including validation error display and navigation back to the album track list.

src/Views/track · high confidence

Introduction of Album domain entities and repository interface

This change introduces the core domain layer for the Album feature, adding the Album entity, its associated exception class, and the repository interface. The Album entity extends CodeIgniter's Entity class and enforces data normalization by automatically capitalizing the first letter of each word in the artist and title fields via their setters. The AlbumNotFoundException provides a specific error handling path for missing albums, while the AlbumRepository interface defines the contract for data access, including methods for finding an album by ID and retrieving paginated results based on a search keyword.

src/Domain/Album · high confidence

Introduction of the Track domain model and repository

This change introduces the core domain components for managing tracks within an album. It adds the Track entity, which stores album ID, title, and author, and automatically capitalizes the first letter of the title and author upon setting. Two exception classes are provided to handle scenarios where a track title is duplicated for a specific album or when a requested track ID is not found. Additionally, the TrackRepository interface defines the contract for data access, specifying methods to find a track by ID and to retrieve paginated track data for a given album, optionally filtered by a keyword.

src/Domain/Track · high confidence

New SQL-based album persistence repository

A new SQLAlbumRepository implementation has been added to handle album data persistence using the CodeIgniter 4 model layer. This repository provides paginated search capabilities by filtering albums via artist or title keywords, retrieves individual albums by ID, and handles deletion with a check on affected rows to ensure data integrity across different database drivers.

src/Infrastructure/Persistence/Album · high confidence

SQL persistence layer for track management

The application now includes a concrete SQL-based repository (SQLTrackRepository) that implements the TrackRepository interface, enabling the storage and retrieval of track data. This component handles paginated track listings filtered by album and search keywords, retrieves individual tracks by ID, and manages track creation and deletion. It enforces data integrity by preventing duplicate track titles within the same album and ensures deletion operations are validated by checking affected database rows.

src/Infrastructure/Persistence/Track · high confidence

Behavioural changes

Add Bootstrap 3 and jQuery to application layout

The application layout view now includes links to Bootstrap 3.4.1 CSS/JS and jQuery 3.4.1 via CDN, enabling the use of Bootstrap styling and JavaScript components in the UI. The previous add and edit album views have been removed, likely as part of a restructuring or migration to a different view strategy, though the specific replacement views are not shown in this diff.

src/Views · medium confidence

Configurable pagination and expanded album-track routing

Users can now customize the number of items displayed per page in album track summaries via the new $paginationPerPage setting in the Album configuration. Additionally, the application exposes new URL routes for managing individual tracks and viewing album track summaries, including endpoints for adding, editing, and deleting tracks within an album context, as well as a totalsong summary view.

src/Config · high confidence

Database migration code style and structure updates

The database migration files in src/Database/Migrations have been refactored to adhere to stricter coding standards. The existing Album migration now uses strict typing (declare(strict\_types=1)), explicit return types (void), and final class declarations, while the new Track migration has been added to define the schema for the track table, including fields for id, album\_id, title, and author, along with a foreign key constraint linking to the album table.

src/Database/Migrations · high confidence

Extracted save() method into DMLPersistence trait

The DMLPersistence trait has been added to src/Infrastructure/Persistence/DMLPersistence.php, encapsulating the save() method logic. This change centralizes the persistence behavior for saving model data, allowing classes to reuse this specific implementation by using the trait rather than duplicating the code.

src/Infrastructure/Persistence · high confidence

Project modernized with PHP 8.2 support and PHPUnit 10 migration

The project has been upgraded to require PHP 8.2 and migrated its test suite to PHPUnit 10, which changes the configuration schema and execution order. To support this, the \phpunit.xml.dist\ and \phpunit.xml.github-actions.dist\ files have been rewritten to use the new XML schema, and a Pyrameter extension has been added to the test bootstrap. Additionally, the repository now includes dedicated configuration files for static analysis and code quality, including \phpstan.neon\, \rector.php\, \phpcs.xml\, \.php-cs-fixer.dist.php\, \infection.json.dist\, and \pyrameter.php\, establishing a standardized workflow for coding standards, type safety, and mutation testing.

(repo-wide) · high confidence

Refactor album and track controllers to use domain repositories and flash messages

The Album and Track controllers have been rewritten to replace direct Model usage with Domain repositories (AlbumRepository, TrackRepository, AlbumTrackSummaryRepository) injected via Services. This change introduces a Post/Redirect/Get pattern for all create, update, and delete actions, replacing previous inline redirects with explicit flash messages for status and error feedback. Additionally, a new AlbumTrackSummary controller has been added to display paginated total song data for albums.

src/Controllers · high confidence

Removal of Album entity with automatic title/artist capitalization

The Album entity class, which previously extended CodeIgniter's Entity and automatically capitalized artist and title strings via setter methods, has been removed from the application. This change eliminates the automatic formatting behavior for album metadata, meaning these fields will no longer be transformed to title case upon assignment.

src/Entities · high confidence

Track model added and Album model validation refined

A new TrackModel has been introduced to manage track data, enforcing validation rules for album\_id, title, and author. The existing AlbumModel has been updated to include a unique constraint on the title field (scoped by album ID) and refined validation for the artist field, while also adopting stricter PHP type declarations and namespace structures.

src/Models · high confidence

Test coverage

Added comprehensive controller tests for Album, Track, and AlbumTrackSummary; Added tests for SQL track repository persistence; Added unit tests for domain entities and exception classes; Added unit tests for the SQL album track summary repository.

Dependencies

Updated PHP and CodeIgniter 4 requirements with new dev tooling and security audit configuration

The project now requires PHP 8.2–8.5 and CodeIgniter 4.7.4 (with a conflict rule preventing earlier framework versions). Development dependencies have been upgraded to include PHPUnit ^11.5, PHPStan ^2.2, Rector dev-main, and new tools like boundwize/structarmed ^0.17 and boundwize/pyrameter ^0.5. Composer config now allows the infection/extension-installer plugin and ignores a specific security advisory (PKSA-z3gr-8qht-p93v). New scripts were added for static analysis, code rectification, coding standard checks, testing, and structural analysis.

(dependencies) · high confidence

Written by watchdog.canine.dev from the codebase's own history, inside the signed delivery this page is composed from.

How this codebase got here

This is the PUBLIC form of this artifact. Findings are listed in full, but the details of SECURITY findings — which rule fired, in which file, on which line, and how to fix it — are deliberately withheld, and any secret-scanner results are excluded entirely. Where detail is absent here it was REMOVED FOR PUBLICATION; it is not missing from the analysis. The complete artifact is available from the repository owner.

Score

  • CAI 64 → 65 (+0.9)
  • Rubric changed (rubric-2026.08.19 → rubric-2026.09.15) — scores are not directly comparable.

Lenses

  • Code Health 99 → 99 (+0.1)
  • Architecture 100 → 82 (-18.4)
  • Maturity 51 → 54 (+3.1)
  • Readiness 70 → 65 (-5.0)
  • Security 75 → 90 (+14.9)
  • Domain Modelling 74 → 79 (+4.3)

Resolved (11)

  • Coverage not included — suite not readable by the collector
  • Dependency hygiene not measured — dependency manifest found but not parsed for hygiene
  • Duplicated block (12 lines × 2) (src/Controllers/Track.php)
  • Duplicated block (9 lines × 2) (src/Controllers/Album.php)
  • High: security finding (details withheld)
  • High: security finding (details withheld)
  • High: security finding (details withheld)
  • High: security finding (details withheld)
  • No exposed public API
  • Off-boarding risk: anonymized user #1
  • Test reliability not included

New (14)

  • Duplicated block (13 lines × 2) (src/Controllers/Album.php)
  • Duplicated block (29–30 lines × 2) (src/Controllers/Track.php)
  • Duplicated block (6 lines × 2) (src/Infrastructure/Persistence/Album/SQLAlbumRepository.php)
  • High: security finding (details withheld)
  • High: security finding (details withheld)
  • High: security finding (details withheld)
  • High: security finding (details withheld)
  • High: security finding (details withheld)
  • Inconsistent naming for ID-based retrieval. The interface methods use 'find...OfId', while the implementation methods also use 'find...OfId'. However, standard repository patterns often prefer 'findById' or 'getById'. More critically, the exception factory methods use 'forAlbumDoesnotExistOfId' and 'forAlbumTrackDoesnotExistOfId', which is verbose and inconsistent with the repository method names.
  • Inconsistent naming for deletion. The base interface uses 'deleteOfId', while the repository pattern often uses 'deleteById'. While consistent within this specific codebase, 'deleteOfId' is less idiomatic than 'deleteById' or 'removeById'.
  • Inconsistent parameter typing for save operations. The base interface DMLRepository requires a non-nullable array, while the concrete implementations (DMLPersistence, SQLTrackRepository) accept nullable arrays (?array). This creates a type mismatch if implementations are expected to strictly adhere to the interface contract without widening the type.
  • Medium: security finding (details withheld)
  • No dependency advisory monitoring
  • Workflow token permissions not restricted

Changes since last survey

  • 6 commits — 6 feature/other, 0 fixes

By area

  • (root) — 4 commits
  • (repo) — 2 commits

Notable commits

  • change: Merge pull request #32 from samsonasik/samsonasik-patch-1
  • change: Merge pull request #33 from samsonasik/samsonasik-patch-1
  • change: Update CodeIgniter framework version to 4.7.4
  • change: Update boundwize/structarmed version to ^0.17
  • change: Update structarmed version to ^0.16
  • change: clean up config

Written by watchdog.canine.dev from the codebase's own history, inside the signed delivery this page is composed from.

Survey your own repository

samsonasik/ci4-album was measured the same way every project in this corpus was: the same rubric, at a pinned commit, with the result published in full. Point a surveyor at a repository you know and see whether you agree with it.

About this page

  • The score is its most recent published measurement, taken on 22 September 2026 at a pinned commit. It is not a live figure and does not change until the project is measured again.
  • Measured at commit 47d3e60ee9f5c504e056536c3c5a39fb3475ca6d — the exact code this score is about.
  • Scored under rubric-2026.09.15 — the same rubric and the same method as every other entry in this index.
  • Measured by watchdog.canine.dev using codehealth-analyzer preprod-821afab8930d.